Moroccan government defends crackdown on proselytisers
2009-04-01
After Moroccan authorities expelled five missionaries, two of the nation's churches denied any official proselytising efforts.
By Sarah Touahri and Naoufel Cherkaoui for Magharebia in Rabat – 01/04/09
![]() [Getty Images] Morocco's "official churches" firmly deny ties with proselytising groups. |
The Moroccan government stressed its commitment to freedom of religion despite the expulsion on Sunday (March 29th) of five Christian missionaries. Officials rejected accusations in the media to the contrary.
According to the judicial police in Casablanca, the five expelled missionaries were arrested on Saturday (March 28th) during a proselytising meeting involving Moroccan nationals. Police officers also seized religious materials including books and videos in Arabic.
Communications Minister and government spokesman Khaled Naciri said that the country upholds freedom of religion, provided proselytising and evangelism are not involved. He explained that churches in Morocco are fully aware of the situation.
The expulsion of the five missionaries -- four from Spain and one from Germany --prompted a response on Monday from Rabat Archbishop Monsignor Vincent Landel and Jean Luc Blanc, pastor of the Evangelical Church of Morocco, denouncing any "proselytising" activity in Morocco.
They were keen to stress the key role played by the "official churches" in supporting Christians living in Morocco.
Landel denied having any links with the missionaries and spoke out against the way that some of the media were grouping them all together.
"Missionaries who come here to convert Muslims have no link with the Catholic Church or with the Protestant Church. It is not in our name that they have obtained their residency permits in Morocco."
The archbishop explained that the mission of the Church in Morocco is to help Christians live out their faith in the recognition that they are in a Muslim country. "We help them enter into an Muslim-Christian dialogue, to respect their Muslim brothers and to trust them," he said.
Such a dialogue rules out any kind of proselytising at the intellectual and theological level, the statement continues. Christians are involved in various activities alongside Muslims who share the same values and objectives, despite their differences.
The issue has raised a fresh debate in Moroccan society.
"Just as Western countries protect secularism and the Christian faith from the spread of Islam, Morocco has the right to protect its religion," said Khalid Cherkaoui Semouni, president of the Moroccan Centre for Human Rights. "This is what Morocco's legislation states, forbidding trying to change individuals' faith. The state has the right to apply the law."
"We cannot speak of freedom of religion in this case, because proselytising relies on changing the other person's faith," explained Lahcen Daoudi of the Islamist Justice and Development Party. "We call on the Moroccan authorities to support those Moroccan associations which work in spreading Islam, as well as imams, and Qur'an study groups. The state cannot face such proselytising efforts alone, and needs the support of civil society to monitor those activities and educational programmes."
When asked about the issue, Moroccans on the street had different opinions about the matter.
"I believe the authorities and the media are blowing the issue out of proportion," said Aya Idrissi, a teacher. "There have been missionaries in Morocco for years, and yet they have had little influence on Moroccans, who stick to their Islam. Besides which, we are a tolerant nation, and we accept all monotheistic religions."
Said Arifat, a law student, disagreed. He noted that many young people are easily influenced by the West and need to be protected. "Missionaries could easily convert them, when this is contrary to the Moroccan constitution."
Moroccan authorities have intensified their efforts recently to stop proselytising activities in the kingdom, arresting several Moroccan Shiites after the government's severance of diplomatic ties with Iran.




J Bush (no relation!) Posted 2009-04-01
The president of the Moroccan Centre for Human Rights seriously mis-states the attitude of the United States government toward religious conversion. There is no government authorized effort to "protect secularism and the Christian faith from the spread of Islam". If this error is the sole basis for his assertion that Morocco has the right to forbid trying to change individuals' faith then the the "right" he asserts vanishes. Were Morocco to imitate the United States policy it might find that Christianity has the same success in Morocco that Islam enjoys in the United States--slowly spreading and finding gradual acceptance among those attracted to its practice. It is not Islam but fundamentalist-inspired terrorism that Americans reject.
عدنان الحسناوى Posted 2009-04-02
What the Moroccan government did is a breach of the freedom of religion. Therefore, it is a breach of human rights. For how long will the citizen stay with no credibility, an individual without responsibility, "underage" and needs the authority of the father to decide on his behalf?
ummunussayr Posted 2009-04-02
These missionaries, does not only existing in our present times, but we find that we have had a long history with them existing in Morocco. However, the Moroccan people even though they were exposed to poverty, ignorance, simplicity and hardships in their lives, they were steadfast in their faith (aqeedah) and could not be swayed easily from their belief. The question we need to ask ourselves is whether our youth of today are going to follow the footsteps of their forefathers or are they going to be inclined toward the materialistic life, which is no longer helpful - perfect example is the West today (America), who is taking a downward spiral in every way, especially spiritually. The danger now, is the fact that our youth, who are more inclined towards the Western idealogies and lifestyles could easily be influenced by these missionaries, seeing it as an escape. Ask any emigrant Moroccan who lives amongst the non-believers, who maybe thought that for them too it was an escape, but now find themselves more steadfast in their Islamic belief than before because they live(d) in the reality of trying to escape their situations in Morocco. Another factor which also should be considered to be a danger to our society is our 2 TV channels (2M and its shakika sister ElMagribiyya) which broadcasts not much interesting programmes but rather more music and naked western lifestyles. Lets ask ourselves, who is going to say something or try to protest about these channels? Nevertheless, a thunderous applause for the Moroccan government for everything they do and especially in trying to protect the Islamic Sunni Maliki doctrine in our great historical country. May Allah protect our youth, our country, our religion and enable us to remain victorious. Murabitun, Muwahidun......
Anonymous Posted 2009-04-02
Christianity does not have relation with secularism. Muslims have all the right to circulate their faith in Europe and to talk their faith to others (Christians) . See the number of the Muslims now and compare it with their number before 20 years. but the Christians do not have the right to circulate their faith in Muslim countries or to talk to any one about it. Why
simo Posted 2009-04-02
I have two remarks to make: First, do we guarantee the freedom of religion in our country or not? There are not 36 thousand answers to this question. Second, if the faith of some “Muslims” is this fragile, then let them try to get to know some other religions if they are healthy adults. According to the precepts of this religion, No one is constrained at all to Islam. Every time there is an article on religion in Morocco, the journalists ask the point of view of someone in charge at the Justice and Development Party. This is quite an aberration because this party is far from being the spokesman for Islam in Morocco. On the contrary, the effort this party makes to “use” Islam - its currency - does serious harm to the religion and to Muslims. Islam has always been was, currently is and will always be a matter of personal conviction, a direct relationship between God and the human being without any intermediary. Islam does not have a clergy and it never will need to have one. A word to the wise! -Bye
hayzoun Posted 2009-04-02
This is wrong! There are hundreds of families in Morocco that practice their Christian faith in secrecy out of fear of police repression. The state prohibits any contact between Moroccans and foreigners, something that holds no guarantees for openness towards the West. No sacred religious places (churches or synagogues) can guarantee the freedom of religion to Moroccan Christians or Jews. Yet, we note the augmentation of Shiite and fundamentalist missions, which are closed to all forms of dialogue and thousands of mosques. The Moroccan state is effectively under the reign of a king, who has full power of the three institutions – legislative, executive and judicial – as well as the constitution and needs to open up in favour of all of his subjects. There you have it: that is what the thousands of Moroccan who are convinced of their new reconversion back to their faith in Jesus. –From Fez, Ahmed Hayzoun
Abu Nussayr Posted 2009-04-03
Praise be to God, peace and prayer be upon the honorable messenger, his family and companions. One of the attitudes for which the Moroccan government is praised is its position for long years as a high mountain to the expansion of Shiism, the sweeping Christian conversion whose presence in Morocco in particular is not random or spontaneous. Its presence is deep in history and the struggle with the Christian West. Someone might wonder about the freedom of religions, religious tolerance hailed by the Moroccan government to this day as many Christian sides hail it. Supposing we blame the position of the Moroccan government for the expulsion of these groups which make people leave their religions on the grounds of freedom of religion, I want to ask a question hoping to find a solution. Would the west which boasts of freedom and freedom of religions authorizes the same thing? Muslims in Europe live in constant fear. They are also subject to numerous and varied prosecutions even in airports. If the non-European is really Christian or imitates them, he is treated very badly. But when the Muslim calls for the religion of God in the West, he does so from his conviction. He doesn't resort to money or temptations which attract some weak-hearted Muslims oppressed by poverty. But the Muslims uses argument, evidence and logic because he knows in his call that he calls for the right. So let them authorize us to call for our religion and we will let them call for their religion without money or temptations. Those who follow them will belong to them and we will thus have achieved the principle of the freedom of religion.
WhoCares Posted 2009-04-05
It's bloody ridiculous. The Qu'ran clearly states there is no compulsion in religion. Yes the West is somewhat in some way scared of Islam taking over, only because loonie Muslims are put in the spotlight as if they represent the majority of Muslims. They represent no more but high television views because it's so controversial. Religion is a personal thing, it doesn't belong to a state or a government. These are the people who have corrupted the faith and I bet you the majority of these lawmakers and Government people who swear by this constitution, are the same ones who drink alcohol, abuse maids and cheat on their wives. All too common, all too clear. That goes for the majority of Arab leaders. I'm Muslim by the way. Not sunni, not shia, not wahhibi, not sufi, not salafist... just Muslim, like God said we should be in the Qu'ran. "Do not part yourselves into sects" !!
Des Fonctionnaires Posted 2009-04-08
The public workers of the Municipality of Paris have also been victims of proselytism. Indeed, they are currently being threatened by certain people in this municipality. Proselytism, suicide, discrimination and working conditions that are becoming ever more deplorable are realities disturbing certain public workers in the municipality of Paris. Here you have it, this is what is really going on in certain parts of the city services: agents have been reporting and lodging complaints with the police for several years now about the proselytising that has been going on at their work place, as well as about harassment and feelings of suicide and depression. Some agents have been depressed for over a year and others are suffering from great moral distress. What has the mayor of Paris done about this? He passed the buck. What did the City of Paris’ courts do? They passed the buck. What did the Office of Human Resources do? They passed the buck. What did the Bureau of Discrimination of Harassment do? They also passed the buck! With the exception of the investigations done on those who filed the charges, which was in disregard for the law protecting public workers, nothing – nothing at all – has been done since 2001. One investigation was even conducted against the victims of such activities by a director that was party to the proselytism at the workplace during work hours. False testimonies, anonymous letters and petitions were recorded in the victims’ administrative files. Some victims were judged by a more than dubious disciplinary council, whose head members at the union headquarters are also party to this affair. Some agents interviewed by the directors we even put…
marroqui de españa Posted 2009-04-08
By God the Greatest, Moroccans don't know what is going on in the country. Everything is manipulated by the government as it wants. But we are watching and don't have what to eat. So we want to immigrate illegally but they closed the door of Harga. Algeria is closing its doors to us and we have nowhere to go. I want to explain to you the saying “The tar of my country is better than honey of other peoples' countries”. I say the tar of other peoples' countries is better than the honey of my country. They made us hate our country. We sue them to God. Where are you media of Morocco? Go see what goes on in Khouribga, the richest city in Morocco, and it is starving. All its people have immigrated illegally. They say God will provide for them. Be sure that a big tumult will happen in Morocco as a result of their acts to us. Where are you media of Morocco? Can't you see or are you with them? Have you ever seen someone living in a villa over 10 kilometres while others in shantytowns, 20 people in a slum? Just compare! But whom I am narrating to? We thank our king Mohamed VI, he alone does projects for us. He is a better king but the dogs didn't let him be merciful to us. May God assist our king. This king is like Mohamed B, when he will die, people will commit suicide on the detriment of...May God assist our king.
hayzoun Posted 2009-04-09
45 plain-clothes police officers with two vans and a jeep forced their way into an apartment where 25 Christians, a man and a child were located. They took their cellular telephones and computers. After humiliating everyone, they all left in the vans. Four Spaniards and one German were expelled, they let the Americans go out of fear of the United States and the Moroccans got three months in prison with reprieve. So, what dialogue of religion are you speaking of? I think the Protestants must love their country and king a lot!
Eng. Hasan Al-Bahkali Posted 2009-04-12
May God help Morocco against its sons. “There is no compulsion in religion; truly the right way has become clearly distinct from error”. The right way has become clearly distinct from error. he right way has become clearly distinct from error. “do not go near prayer”: “do not go near prayer when you are Intoxicated”. Many refer to part of a verse such as “ There is no compulsion in religion” but the right is “ There is no compulsion in religion; truly the right way has become clearly distinct from error”; and this example “ do not go near prayer” but the right is : “do not go near prayer when you are Intoxicated”. If just the last part of the verse is referred to, the meaning is incomplete. Engineer Hasan Al Bahkali.
hayzoun Posted 2009-05-29
With God as my witness, I do not know what is happening to our Moroccan citizens. Islam is not a “man” – not even Christianity is. These are ideas able to be discussed, and every human being has the right to accept them or not. Yet, we know that a handful of politicos possess all the country’s resources, the Royal Family takes one third of the state budget for itself every year, all juridical and legislative power is concentrated in the hands of the monarchy. The ministers are only functionaries enforcing royal directives, and the parliamentarians are functionaries too. The problem for us Moroccans is the representation of the people and democracy. All of our rights are under at mast. Our individual liberties are being monitored. Poverty is increasing, as are unemployment and delinquency. Only a fair constitution which treats all Moroccans – men and women – equally can save us from under-development and illiteracy, which thoroughly envelop us. But, the fact of adoring Jesus or Mohamed can under no circumstances shake anyone else’s father, what ever it may be. –Ahmed Hayzoun
مسيحي مغربي Posted 2009-08-25
God has made for every person a plan in his life. Every one of us has a mind with which to think. Every person distinguishes the evil from the good. I knew Jesus through the internet. No proselytizer or foreigner talked to me. I don't deny the presence of proselytizers in Morocco. But I think that Morocco and all Islamic countries try hard to stop the growth of Christians. In Europe there are many Muslim preachers who talk about their religion freely. No one stands in their way. But in Islamic countries, it is the opposite. Christians cannot talk about their religion.
hamou Posted 2009-09-28
This is not acceptable. What the government did was the right thing.
wikings Posted 2009-12-02
What's going on in the Muslim countries doesn't surprise me. A country that doesn't know true democracy can't tolerate religious freedom. More than 400 years ago in France, we experienced this when the Catholics would go after the Protestants. Our revolution in 1789, with the “Rights of Man”, put an end to this inequality. Thank God for this, because the Jews and Protestants had been considered second-class citizens and did not have the same rights. What is going on now is simply the Islamist extremists imposing their murky views of religion and being unable to tolerate that people can see God in their own way. And, since they have a big influence on the poorest people, we understand these deviations. In France, a Muslim can practice his religion without problem, but in a personal way. Christians are in the same boat, nothing more, nothing less. The only thing they are asked is to respect the laws of the republic. France is a secular country; thus, no religion should prevail over any other. I read the entire Quran and I found it very violent and with intolerant verses. I remain perplexed when I am told that Islam is a religion of love and tolerance. But, if Christians truly followed the words of Jesus, we should never have war in the world and, more especially, Europe. May peace be upon men of good will. -Patrick
ibrahim Posted 2010-07-17
i very rarely 'blog' however uopon reading these comments i felt it my duty to. re: wikings Posted 2009-12-02 secularism in europe caused all the fighting over the centuries it didnt remove it!! if christian countries had christian rulership none of the european wars would of happened read your bible from cover to cover, you will find christianity to be the violent religion true religion like islam seeks to destroy the illnesses of the heart and indirectly seeks to eliminate the causes of war such as intolerance, racism, tribalism, greed, love of land, love of money, love of power, love of position. re: مسيحي مغربي Posted 2009-08-25 you say that christians cannot openly talk about thier religion, lets put things in perpective, in muslim countries muslims cannot openly talk about their religion. also muslim countries try even harder to stop the growth of islam than they do to stop the growth of christianity because it means the loss of their own rulership. islam seeks to win over the hearts of all of mankind. will that be acheived by hating and alienating people??
We welcome your comments on Magharebia's articles.
It is our hope that you will use this forum to interact with other readers across the Maghreb. In order to keep this experience interesting, we ask you to follow the rules outlined in the comments policy. By submitting comments, you are consenting to these rules. While Magharebia.com encourages discussion on all subjects, including sensitive ones, the comments posted are solely the views of those submitting them. Magharebia.com does not necessarily endorse or agree with the ideas, views, or opinions voiced in these comments. This is a moderated forum. Comments deemed abusive, offensive, or those containing profanity may not be published.
Magharebia's Comments Policy