امل Posted 2007-04-23

Congratulations for the return of Yousri to the race. Yousri has a beautiful and strong voice. Yousri will be the star. Yousri, all Tunisia is with you!

siham Posted 2007-04-23

This is really great

مهند الليبي Posted 2007-04-23

Salam Alaikoum...I want to say that the Moroccan and Algerian dialects are difficult to pronounce for the Libyan students Khairi and Ahmed in star academy. I ask the supervising teachers to take that into consideration...In other words, like Moroccan and Algerian contestants who are offered songs in their countries, Libyan students should be given Libyan or Arabic songs...I think that the popularity of star academy is recessing because that point wasn't taken into consideration...Thanks anyway.

الملكة Posted 2007-04-24

An unsuccessful program guided by fancies and plans; things will not go right in the presence of a person like Hicham. Things have greatly improved without him, he makes the overture without his rabble (the gates of the hell) which are never closed, we need ( a very very personal referendum) of Hamid, Badrou, Farid, Jamal, Khairi…and so on if someone else other than Yousra were to get the exception? Or the staff directing the program were found out as after top 5 you get out of the house or were the teachers fed up with her arrogance, disrespect and wanted to punish her thinking that she’ll come back with the votes of the viewers who follow the slightest details, on the other hand her friends didn’t want her to return because of her bad attitude and apparent selfishness, expect Mr Nabil El Khaldi more cries, and the question that imposes itself is it an over-emotion or is it a play acted successfully by the actor Hicham willing as he’s supervising the program to extort the viewers and more and more dirhams and dinars forgetting that respect to the intelligence of the viewer and credibility should be a priority not at the bottom of the list!! And Mrs Ilham surprises, who is contradictory in her affirmations, surprises us with a discourse lacking transparency, contradiction, bias, impartiality and showing much more of what’s happening in the coulisses, the improvised decisions show a weakness in the administration, and in order to achieve a material profit, the administration should be unfair, and the contract of the corrupt administration is crowned after Khadija, Hicham and Ilham with Mr Nabil El Khaldi, Abdelmajid who have no character, and Mr Abdelhamid who invented his presence in the committee wherein he has no weight, and Mr Ghazi whom I’ve seen most of the times diverting his eyes, because the grade was put previously in the house and not from the effort on the stage, Mr Abdelhamid Kiassi is excluded from all that, he has added a positive charge to the students as he represents the nice era, and Anis and Sonia with their high spirits. To those responsible for the management of the unsuccessful Arab Maghreb academy learn lessons from the successful programs such as Super Star first part, when Moulhim went out, Lebanese made demonstrations for his return but the director of the program refused in spite of the approval of Diana Karzouane and Rouayda Atia and said that the game is like that, and Ilyass Rahbani who makes of the modesty of the students and their lack of arrogance the first lesson for the one who wants to become an artists as our Arab worlds doesn’t need an arrogant adolescence, she could have learnt the first lesson in life, Mrs Khadija should have invited her to attend the first prime ( as guest of honor). It has become quite clear that the dirty game is targeting the pockets and not diffusing the Maghreb art which was the only concern and objective according to the statement of El Karoui. And we found French, English and Spanish songs to complete the contract of countries that have colonized our Great Arab Maghreb. You young people of the Arab Maghreb should go to other successful programs like super star, Lebanon star academy and most recently album where talents from North Africa (Tunisia, Morocco, Libya) receive high training, coaching and fame. Beware you Maghreb people as the scheme is well combined the nominee will be either Maghrebian or Libyan to ensure more extortion, beware.

lakder39 Posted 2007-04-24

I love you so much badro and I am cheering you on. God willing, you will be the star of Star Academy Maghreb. From he bottom of my heart I hope everything will work out for you. Kisses.

صوفيا Posted 2007-04-24

I suggest to Nesma channel to broadcast star academy around the clock 24/24 like other reality TV programs and bring football players from Morocco

طارق Posted 2007-04-24

Thank you for the program we love you

SARA Posted 2007-04-24

I like you so much Hamid Sara from Algeria

samira Posted 2007-04-24

I love you so much, Hajar.

zitouni Posted 2007-04-24

Frankly, Star Academy is worthless. Why did Dounia and Yosra make it back: you’ve made them hate each other. Ferass is cruel and vicious; he is not like the others. Khairi sings better than Soraya, so why is he nominated every time. Be honest with your votes. Thank you.

غبد القادر Posted 2007-04-24

I love you so much Hajar and I encourage you. Inchallah you'll be the star of the Star Academy Maghreb program. I hope from the bottom of my heart that everything goes well for you. Kisses

karima Posted 2007-04-24

Hi, you've turned out to be the opposite of what was expected everyone is playing on hypocrisy everyone is only concerned about himself it's really a pity

mouhamede Posted 2007-04-24

First of all a greeting to all contestants namely the Algerians who remind us of Rim Ghazali, I want to ask my darling Khadija to change advertising rules and position of nominees, I also want to say that I live in Lebanon and the Lebanese people encourage the contestants I also have friends in Egypt who called me and congratulated me for the Maghreb star academy and that they encourage Algerians

achraf Posted 2007-04-24

Long live hamid you're honouring the north you've a great personality

zahra fares Posted 2007-04-25

Hello, I would like to say that Star Academy Maghreb is great. I just have one suggestion: I would love it if Friday nights were held live for a public audience.

jalila Posted 2007-04-25

I am not against Yosra, it is true she has a great voice. In spite of that, law can't be diverted.

رانيا Posted 2007-04-25

I love you Hajar, God help you, please God, please God make her win together with other Moroccans, please God, you should honour us you the nicest so that Algerians see who are Moroccans

سليمان Posted 2007-04-25

Salam Alaikoum, where are modern songs in your program? I noticed that most songs that the students sing are old, what about modern songs are there of no use? where are the songs of Hamid Chairi, Cheb Khaled, Saber Roubaii...of the nicest songs

غغغ Posted 2007-04-25

My vote for Jamal young people

امال Posted 2007-04-25

Farid a star and Dounia out

ميلود على Posted 2007-04-25

I say to Firas you're boring please try to lessen that I'm from Libya

محفوض Posted 2007-04-25

3 4 1 2 Jamal a star Dounia Yousra out out

جويرية Posted 2007-04-25

I encourage all the students namely the Chehrazad of the Sahara Hajar, Abdelhamid and the nice Farah

محيؤز من الجزائر Posted 2007-04-25

Jamal a star Jamal a star

habiba Posted 2007-04-26

salamou alicom I wich yousra stay because she is the best

علي الجزائري Posted 2007-04-26

First of all I congratulate all the Arab Maghreb for this program through which we'll be able to diffuse our culture to all the world, I wish success to the program and all the students. May God grant them success and honour us in front of all nations...

عماد Posted 2007-04-26

Let's unite and vote against Yousra and drive her out of the academy

randa Posted 2007-04-26

I like kaoutar and Abdelhamid so much and the very nice Farah, I say to Dounia bye, to Fatin and Yousra work hard and in fact I love you all

فادية Posted 2007-04-27

I vote for Algerians Dounia, Badrou, Farid we love you so much and inchallah one of you a star bye

hamza yousef Posted 2007-04-27

hi to ahamea jamal,kaere,hajr,hameed,badro,fatn,fared,sriea,farh,dnea,.and i would like to say that,it was nice program befor they breked the law of it and allow nomeneted people to returen,it was ingusted hamza libya

maamar Posted 2007-04-27

I love you, Faten. This is Farid Ferhaoui from Algiers.

سهام تمكروت زاكورة المغرب Posted 2007-04-27

Salam Alaikoum, I love you so much Hamid, Kawtar, Hajar, Farah, and namely Yosra you're stars...Yosra please sing to me 'Yak Ajerhi'

هيفاء Posted 2007-04-27

I would like to greet our Libyan youth and all Libyans are with you, I'm Aicha from Paris, I love you so much, encourage you and vote for you. God with you we love you madly.

wafae Posted 2007-04-28

I'm Moroccan, I want to say that Faten is the sweetest in the Dar. Please support her because she deserves to continue in the competition and I like Hajar

zineb Posted 2007-04-28

Salam I'm Zineb from Morocco I want to say that Hajar is the star and she's the nicest girl, Hamid, Farah, and Kawtar I wish you success and Morocco forever, I love you so much, good luck

ليبي للمليون Posted 2007-04-28

Firstly, the program is very nice, it introduces to the Maghreb viewer the nice songs of the Arab Maghreb, I wish success to the program. I like Badrou, Ahmed, Khairi and Hamid. I think that there were serious errors "for example the return of the students to the house" Thanks (your brother Libyan for the million)

اسماعيل Posted 2007-04-28

Ahmed a star

نفيسة Posted 2007-04-28

In my opinion, and after Fatin went out while Yosra and Dounia are still there, namely because Fatin has a very nice voice better than Dounia and many of those who are there. Everything is by favouritism, this was evident in the prime when Yosra and Dounia were rescued by the public. I know no one who encourages Dounia.

nin a Posted 2007-04-28

i hat u kawtar

شيماء Posted 2007-04-28

I like all the students of star academy namely Hamid, Kawtar, Hajar and you Hamid a star and love you so much, Chaima from Morocco (Tangier)

محمد Posted 2007-04-29

Why this excessive interest in the form or rules, what's important is the aim of the program which is to show the Maghreb repertoire and genre, and preserve it..Look at star academy Lebanon which has chosen "interest" as an objective, just remember Hicham (money) and Chada (politics) and others. But Maghreb people are subject either to early elimination (the Algerian, Libyan, Moroccan) as for Tunisians they keep them as they need them in some concerts in Tunisia. In addition, the most prominent of them sing in Lebanese!!!!Total contempt for the Maghreb people and their culture,,, long live the Great Maghreb

manel Posted 2007-04-29

Hello Star Academy. I give a big kiss to Jemal and Donia.—from Algiers.

دوسة Posted 2007-04-29

Ahmed is certainly a star- we love you madly! And Khairi is a star.

عبدالرحمن عزيز Posted 2007-04-29

I will say it frankly, the Dar has become lonesome after the departure of Fatin the brilliant who has made me follow most of the life in the Dar, she's the worthiest student of the Arab Maghreb star title, but luck wasn't on her side, in general, if voting was by emotion, it would have been for Ahmed and Khairi, but with the artistic standards, I'll support Fatin even after her departure because she has huge artistic powers, besides her remarkable presence with her character and eastern beauty, signed A charmed by Fatin Abderrahmane from Libya.

nahed Posted 2007-04-29

A program not to the level

محمد Posted 2007-04-29

Farah I love you so much, both your look and your voice, I wish you a successful career and you're a star, your lover Laksibi

samiha Posted 2007-04-29

My name is Samiha and I am from Morocco. I love all four of the Moroccans, Farah, Hajar, Kawtar and Hamid. I am sure that, in the end, Hajar will be the star. A big kiss to Farah!

siham123 Posted 2007-04-29

That's very good and nice the most beautiful in you is Hamid by God, Kawtar, Hajar and Ahmed I liked you when you danced that Hindi dance it suits you really and I hope from God that you're all well salam to all the students of the academy, bye, salam

redouane Posted 2007-04-29

very nice program... in spite of you, you Lebanon you racist

khawla Posted 2007-04-30

I really love Nessma TV. My favorites are Abdel, Hamid, Hajar, Kawtar, and Farah. But, I don’t like Yosra and Ahmed.—Firas

نوسة Posted 2007-04-30

Where is the Arabic? They don't speak it- not teachers or students. Unfortunately, the name of the program is Star Academy Arab Maghreb, but why not change its name to Star Academy French Maghreb? And why don't you put a translation on the screen when you show us the daily life of the students. Teachers should speak in the Arabic language and not ignore them. Because when they speak French, they're unfair to the two Libyan students Ahmed and Khairi. Namely in the courses, as the students are entitled to understand what goes on in the courses. We claim the Arabic language, as in Libya our culture is Italian, and despite that, Ahmed and Khairi don't speak it out of respect for our Arab Maghreb and the Arabic language. We ask for a translation- on Lebanon Star Academy, even if they speak many languages, they know that there are people who don't understand them like the Arab Maghreb and the Gulf. Our greetings to Mr. Nabil El Khalidi and the sweet Jamal, the beautiful Kawtar, the great Khairi, the handsome and funny Ahmed.

فرج Posted 2007-04-30

A warm greeting...from the heart of Libya I send my warmest greetings to friend Ahmed the superstar, I tell him be steady on the path of star, inchallah from any hurdles.

hamza Posted 2007-04-30

I love Jamel. He has a beautiful voice, as do Farid and Badro.

dou3ae Posted 2007-04-30

I would like to say to Yosra that you are my favourite girl. Keep up the good work. Good Luck! I am sending you a big kiss. I loooooooove you. This is Dozia from Kénitra, Morocco.

siham Posted 2007-04-30

I like Hajar,Kawtar and Ahmed without forgetting Fatin because she's the friend of the Moroccan Kawtar, but you Farah I like you but I don't appreciate some of your deeds, my greetings to everyone in the Dar with my love Siham.

khaled Posted 2007-04-30

Hi Hajar, Abdel, Ahmed, Kawtar and Farah. I love you, Hajar. Please, god willing, win!

houssam Posted 2007-05-01

I love Hamid, Kawtar, Farah, Hajar, and all of the Moroccans.

الهام Posted 2007-05-01

Hamid don't forget that you were born in Chaouen, it's the origin

zizo Posted 2007-05-01

I'm Ghizlane I wish to Khayri good luck and I'm fond of him, inchallah you're the star, I love you so much Khayri, a big kiss to all the students

kawtar Posted 2007-05-01

I love you all, especially Farah, Badro and Yosra. Good luck to you! See you soon.

hassna Posted 2007-05-02

Greetings to everyone- in fact, I was expecting a great prime but the studio is very small... not even big enough for the students! There isn't a big audience and they are in a chaos, unorganized, there's no respect as in the clothing or fashion, the dresses are old-fashioned, as if they bought them from the flea market or stole them, they put on too much make up, if you had brought aesthetics experts from Lebanon they would have become different, to sum up, very old fashioned people, and if you can't do something in a good way, do not do it at all. the starac is bad bad bad

ملاك Posted 2007-05-02

There's a total partiality ((Yosra)) on the side of the direction of the acdemy which lessens the interest of the Maghreb viewer to watch the program in this week she made a mistake but didn't drop out of the six nominees we ask the direction of the academy to be firm and not be kind to the student because this is a game and only those who deserve will remain whether by the voting of the public or rescue by the students

manal sayem Posted 2007-05-02

I love you, Kawtar, Badro, Khairi, Hajr, Abdel, Hamid and Farah. I love you so much, Star Academy Maghreb.

nada Posted 2007-05-02

Salam alaikoum, I wish success to all the students and I say that Yosra deserves to come back because she's a very nice voice and I say to Fatin you're a star and May God help you succeed, a special greeting to Ahmed Khairi Yosra Hajar Jamal and Kaoutar inchallah the star is one of you, Nada from Libya

حنان Posted 2007-05-02

I love you so much Hajar and wish you success over all, my greetings to Abdelhamid and I encourage him as well, with success, Hanane from Casablanca

ismail benkhdda Posted 2007-05-02

Salam Alaikoum stars of Star Academy mainly Farah, to Farah I say you're on the top I hope you'll be the star I watch you daily in the end I say it's nice that you've a heart you own but the best is that you be the heart my friend- I love you more than my sister and wish you happiness in the world and the other life I have a small request please sing me a song you love thanks

بنت ليبيا Posted 2007-05-03

Salam Alaikoum, my greetings to Ahmed and Khairi and also to Badrou and Farid, we tell them you're the stars and may God make you succeed (a special thank to all the staff of this successful and special program) hoping that they'll take into consideration a few things in the prime, with my greetings I love you

احلام Posted 2007-05-03

I love Hamid, Hajar and Farah and I want from Hajar a song of Latifa Raafat

سنونو Posted 2007-05-03

I'm Sanounou from Libya, I want to say that all participants are good but of course Khairi and Ahmed are the best and inchallah will go to the end we Libyans are with you forever

ouahiba Posted 2007-05-04

I am very proud of Star Academy. Thank you, Tunisia. Honestly, I was waiting on this for such a long time. Hamdoullah, that meant a lot to me when you invited the tennis player and the arbiter out. That was very nice and also very principled. Hi sat down to a table, he played ball. Long live Star Academy.—Ouhiba, an Algerian, from Paris.

رابطة هاجر Posted 2007-05-04

In fact I liked this program but when Fatin went out it became without value because Fatin was the leader of the Dar and I love Hajar so much

wafae Posted 2007-05-04

I love Fatin, Kawtar and Khairi, shame on you Mrs Khadija, it's really a shame

فؤاد Posted 2007-05-04

I encourage Dounia a lot and I hope from my heart that she'll succeed. Can you sing for me a song of Cheb Housni. Fouad from Algeria.

jamila Posted 2007-05-04

Hi everyone, Bravo Ahmed and Hamid! You are super! Good luck and may God bless you.-Jamila from Morocco

khadija Posted 2007-05-05

I'm Khadija from Morocco inchallah and whatever happens Hajar is the star of the Great Arab Maghreb. I love Kaoutar so much and I'm side for her departure she should have stayed among the top, but they betrayed her because they've not voted for her. But I say to Kaoutar don't be sad it's not a must to stay in the Dar you should show them outside the Dar, Kaoutar tomorrow work hard and show us what you can do some single and we're waiting for you and we're always with you

maroc Posted 2007-05-05

Hello, I love you all. Hamid, I am very proud of you. Hajar, I adore hw you sing. Farah, you make me crazy when yu speak Arabic. Farid, I love your personality.-A big kiss to all of you and Badro

مروان من الجزائر Posted 2007-05-06

I hope that the rules of the administration are changed I encourage Badrou the son of Oued Souf, with success

sanae Posted 2007-05-06

This is Sanay from Morocco. I am sending you a giant kiss, Hajar!

العايب Posted 2007-05-06

mc Ahmed+Hajar the nicest two in the academy, I'm Alaib I love you so much and tell you inchallah you're the stars I want Ahmed to sing a song by Faouzi Mezdaoui

نورالدين Posted 2007-05-06

mc Ahmed+Hajar+Khairi we love you so much and namely the beauty queen of the academy Hajar and of course we don't forget the leader Ahmed sing a song by the group Tair El Abiad

aziza Posted 2007-05-07

I would like to say to the woman who said close the door and give the keys to the owner that the river is just drop by drop to fill and I encourage Hajar, Ahmed, Farah and Badrou I love you to death may God protect you and I add even Soraya, Yousra, and Jamal

asmae Posted 2007-05-07

I love you, Hajar, because you are so beautiful. You are the star of Morocco. KISSESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!

amina el.rhannai Posted 2007-05-07

Hi, BRAVO Hajar, Yosra and Farah! Keep up the good work.

Anonymous Posted 2007-05-07

Ahmed blooming, Ahmed keep on being strong and rid us of the feeling of losers...Bechara Libya

hamada Posted 2007-05-07

My Dear Hamid from Casa, bless you! I want to tell you, Hamid, that your song, “Nass I Ghiwan,” was over the top. And one other thing: why did you give the nix to Casawi????????????????????????? Why were you for Donia and not Kawtar? You didn’t even help. If I were of your nationality, I would have never voted like you did.

amine Posted 2007-05-08

Bravo everyone!!! I love you Hajar. –Amine from Morocco

سليمان Posted 2007-05-08

I want to congratulate you for this great program gathering the Arab Maghreb, so more work and effort, I congratulate Libyan young people and wish them success, with many thanks

هشام Posted 2007-05-08

the jury should be firm in its decisions, for example Yousra who made several mistakes and necessary measures weren't taken.

sokaina Posted 2007-05-09

Bravo Ahmed, Hajar, Yosra and Soraya! You are the best!

ليلي من ليبيا Posted 2007-05-09

I would like to say to everyone who encourage Ahmed and Khairi I wish them success inchallah in star academy even if we know that this program is totally unsuccessful, we say to Khadija you know the Tunisian star, I say that this was designed to take the Libyans so that we vote, you want our money, but God is with us

رمزي الليبي Posted 2007-05-09

I wish to brothers Ahmed and Khairi success in this competition the first of its kind in the Great Arab Maghreb, I say to Ahmed, don't worry, we and all your fans in the Great Arab Maghreb will vote for you so that you give more with your lightheartedness and starring in Maghreb star academy.

joudia Posted 2007-05-10

Good evening everyone, I love all of you without exception. But, I would like to say to Hajar that you’re a cute girl and I adore you. Keep up the good work and strive with all your might to be the star. You are the best since Studio 2M.

kari Posted 2007-05-11

Bravo everyone! I love you, Farah, Yosra, Hajar and also Abdel and Hamid (a Moroccan.) Keep up the good work. I would like to say: Long Live Star Academy and Long Live Morocco!

بنت القبائل Posted 2007-05-12

Azul, bravo Farid, you're the best and the strongest, you have a very special personality, you're the sun of the star academy, you're the bright star of Algeria and the Kabyle, I ask you a Kabyle song of Maatoub or Mohamed Alaoua, my kisses, Nassima Nkaous, Batna

سنونو Posted 2007-05-13

I send the nicest greetings to the nicest two young men in the academy (Ahmed and Khairi) inchallah one of you will be the star. I also send to Bas Ayoune Libya, Ramzi the Libyan, Laila from Libya, and Mohanad the Libyan, I tell them God bless you for your sweet opinions I'm (Sanounou Misrata) pray for me I'm studying in the third year medicine.

messa Posted 2007-05-13

We want the starac to be 24 and the clothes of the students better, we encourage all the sons of my country 123 long live Algeria

ahmed Posted 2007-05-13

Long Live Star Academy Maghreb!

سليم Posted 2007-05-13

You've lost the best voice in the academy, you've lost Jamal and he's the beauty of voice

كخاضكثي لاقضاكه Posted 2007-05-13

Hi, how are you, my greetings to all the star academy I wish success to Hajar, Hamid and all the contestants

نعمة Posted 2007-05-14

I wish success to all and of course the best will win, I'm Naama from Libya

سعادالجزائر Posted 2007-05-14

Salam Alaikoum Algerians you're overwhelming, Ahmed we love you so much, you and Khairi have to learn French, Farid bring us some Kabyle

ohib maryem Posted 2007-05-14

Where are the days of Fatin and Kawtar, the Dar without them is valueless, it's better that Dounia goes out because she doesn't deserve to stay, about the best voice in the Dar it's the Hajar and Firas, I love Khairi and Ahmed so much, and on this occasion I want to say to Nessma may God preserve you for us I would also like to say to all to all viewers to pray for the dear sister Maryem to recover quickly, Oh God, pray for her

ليلى عين البيضاء Posted 2007-05-14

You've lost the best voice in the academy, you've lost Jamal, he's the beauty of the voice

الساكر زكريا Posted 2007-05-14

Hello

SANA Posted 2007-05-15

Badrou, you're the best one in the academy after Ahmed, salam to Khairi and Hajar, Sanaa from Libya

نعمة المغربية Posted 2007-05-15

Salam alaikoum, a greeting to all the organizers of star Arab Maghreb star academy. I'm a viewer of the program, as a comment: the first mistake committed by the program is the return of Dounia and Yousra. Because this situation affects following results. A greeting to all participants. But Hajar we were trusting your vote, but this week you have disappointed us with your vote for Dounia instead of Jamal, we sympathize with Dounia, but Jamal is better than Dounia and deserves to remain, we love Jamal by his behaviour and voice in the Dar, now I can't follow the program without the presence of Jamal, and this isn't my opinion I transmit the opinion of most viewers. Thank you.

علي محمد Posted 2007-05-15

Salam alaikoum, I agree with you Sanaa that Ahmed and Khairi are the best students in the academy, I hope that the star is from Libya, and inchallah it will be Ahmed because he's lighthearted

وسام ابو القاسم عبد الله امليحة Posted 2007-05-16

I encourage Ahmed among the young people, he's the best voice, Khairi and Hajar are the nicest voices in the academy, one of them deserves to be a star.

maryem Posted 2007-05-16

If Khairi leaves the Dar the program should be stopped, because it will no longer have any value. Dounia should leave and Farah- no look and no voice, it's better that they take the initiative and leave the Dar, this is an advice to them.

على Posted 2007-05-16

Success to all inchallah

اسماعيل غلام Posted 2007-05-16

I vote for Khairi and Ahmed, and namely Khairi, his voice is nice, with my greetings, Ismail Ghoulam, thank you

angel Posted 2007-05-17

Hi, Khairi only, Ahmed only; Libya only

باص عيون ليبيا14 Posted 2007-05-17

In reply to brother Sami from Tunisia contributing on this great site, and to all brothers who deal with Maghreb art and personality with a local limited racist view, they should take the example of Cheikh Ifrit who have enriched and collected the Maghreb heritage in Tunisia from the thirties of last century, he's a researcher and true artist, he made up a rich library of the Maghreb heritage, culture and art, he's the son of a Moroccan father and Libyan mother, he isn't Jewish, according to what was said in cultural forum on the Tunisian satellite channel Hannibal...last week. We hope that brothers Karoui take note and consider that.

هاجر Posted 2007-05-17

It's Hajar, the name of Hajar is from Morocco, I love you, you've honoured the star, I pray with you

سيف - من ليبيا Posted 2007-05-18

Hi, in fact I liked Hajar, a strong voice, and a strong presence, she sings most of the music types greatly, and even the Libyan songs she sings them greatly, even better than the Libyans Khairi and Ahmed, I don't like Khairi and hope that he will leave because he's childish, but Ahmed, he reaaly deserves to be the star. Yousra has undeoubtedly a strong voice, but her return to the Dar was a big mistake which threatened the credibility of the prohram. Farah has a nice voice but only the problem of the Arabic language, Soraya a strong presence, but her voice is a bit weak with my respects, Firas a strong character with a good presence, Badrou has the best character and I believe he's the kindest and the problem of the Arabic language threatens him as well like Farah. Dounia has a weak voice, but she's the only who sings in a good way some slow songs. Hamid and Farid are great and the best for me, my only reproach is the violation of the rules of the game by the committee which made the program lose its credibility, you're bright

Anonymous Posted 2007-05-18

Ilove you so much farah hager and hamid after that good luck

خليفة عبد النور القدرابو Posted 2007-05-19

The nicest voice in the star academy is Ahmed and Khairi, my greetings to the guys Jamal, Farid, Hamid, Badrou and Firas

هلا Posted 2007-05-19

Salam alaikoum, there's a great partiality towards Tunisians and a disinterest towards Libyans whom we feel are unwanted as we give them difficult songs

kawtar hamada Posted 2007-05-19

I'm Kawtar from Morocco (Casa) I love Hajar she'll be the star inchallah

mah Posted 2007-05-19

I would like to respond to Malika. I see you have something against Hichem, but I’d like to say something myself: His is the best in all of Star Academy. So keep your opinions to yourself. You’re a failure, that’s all.

salma Posted 2007-05-20

Hi to all the candidates, I wish all of you good luck, especially Abdel, Hamid, Hajar and Farah, you are the children of our homeland. I love you. KISSES

simohamed Posted 2007-05-20

Bravo Moroccans, but shame on you Abdelhamid, you should have voted for Kawtar, Bravo Hajar, but you Farah you should be proud of being Moroccan, what's the matter with you? Simo from Fkih Ben Salah, Morocco

هدى Posted 2007-05-20

I'm Houda from Algeria, a student in the Arts Institute. Thank you for this program, but its level of success is less than 10 percent. That's due to any negative aspects, that are appearing in the program in grading and the choice of songs for the students, because we see that the votes for the students are violated, like Yosra for example, they're wondering why did she return, I say that the reason is that transparency and integrity are missing, she has a great voice, we in the institute give an example of her voice, it's said that she has the voice of Rebab, and I'm not the one who evaluate her, but it's the evaluations of teachers who have high diplomas in music, and we are in front of Maghreb star academy and not Europe star academy, so why are they evaluating the students with European songs, and we're not Europeans, we're looking for the star, as for beauty and smartness they have their field, we're in front of the art of music, so we ask you please with all respect and esteem to take care of that because the program is threatened and the right person isn't in the right place, the impartiality of the teachers, evaluation for the essence and it's the voice and if it's with dancing, it should be for all students, and be careful, because after the departure of Jamal, Yosra, Ahmed, Hajar or Farid, we want the star to be among these students, and we say to Ghazi we're one Maghreb Arab nation, so be impartial, special thanks to Ilham, you're one of the best and fairest teachers, thanks with the greetings of the student of the Art Institute in Algeria and good luck to the jewel voice Yosra

ماجدة لينا Posted 2007-05-20

The most charming, beautiful and smartest in the academy is of course Farid, by God, he's very good in singing, dancing and acting. He's always smiling, and above all, he has a big heart, and adds a beauty to the villa. He's a real artist, I like so much his famous saying 'Art isn't something easy, you have to be patient'. He understands the value of art and he's aware that artistic success can be achieved only through hard work. The nicest thing is that he sings well in the Amazigh language, gives it a more acceptable spirit for the listener, and he's the only one there to present the Kabyle Amazigh heritage which undoubtedly reflects the civilization of the Arab Maghreb. He has truly embodied the idea of the program and its ultimate objective. May God protect you for us and make you win the title of the Arab Maghreb star, become a big star and be the successor of the big stars Idir, Ait Mounkalt and others. You're the pride of Algeria and we love it to the bone, my kisses to the nicest Farid

درنه _ ليبيـــــــــــــــــــــــا Posted 2007-05-21

This is really a nice program but there are a few things that are missing concerning the administration of the program and the arrangement of songs to students, as the student thinks about how to sing but finds difficulty in singing and tries to memorize the song without understanding its meaning, our hearts are with Ahmed the nice, Khairi the smart, my greetings to teachers of the academy namely Hicham the very creative artist ((we love you Ahmed and Khairi)).

sawsan Posted 2007-05-21

Sawsan has got it right.

hamid Posted 2007-05-21

You are my star.

هند Posted 2007-05-22

We all encourage the Moroccan Hajar and the Libyan Ahmed, the nicest duo.

محمدأستاذ الموسيقى من الجزائر Posted 2007-05-22

From following this academy which pretends to promote the Maghreb heritage, we have noticed that its administration has made a mistake by bringing back Yosra two days after her departure and added Dounia so as to delude the viewers and followers of the life of the students in the Dar that it changed its mind, I say that the return of Dounia after one week to disguise the total partiality to Yousra, why didn't they return Yousra before the exit of Yousra, or how else can we explain that? Partiality was evident in several situations, for example in the exam before the jury, Yousra has stopped during the song and went away from the jury disappointed and lost a witness to herself for all the problems she faces every time before the jury and despite that she wasn't a nominee even among 6. In addition to the irrational grading of the students, during the prime Mr Ghazi awards the best 14 to Tunisians and only 12 to 13 to the best Algerian, Moroccan or Libyan student. I also thank Khairi for his withdrawal because he really felt the injustice he suffered in grading, in the prime Khairi was awarded 14 whereas Yousra had 12.75 and after the exam of Sunday Khairi goes out as a nominee while Yousra stays. We notice this in its slightest details. N.B. Why are the grades of the exams not shown directly on the screen so that the viewers can see them? Why are they hidden? What's the secret behind that? If you want to imitate the Lebanon star academy you should avoid these negative points. The proverb says, If the raven tries to imitate the partridge, he forgets his own way of walking. Finally, I hope that these weak points do not affect the credibility of the Arab Maghreb star academy which have begun in its first weeks of life.

سعودية تعشق بدرو Posted 2007-05-22

Salam alaikoum, please less French, we want to watch the program but we don't understand anything, for the artist Badro, he has a great voice and his presence is great, I follow the program just for his sake, his departure is a loss for the program, I wish you success forever, I love you so much Badro, please vote for him.

soraya/algerie/batna Posted 2007-05-23

Salam Alaikoum, I'm SOraya from Algeria, I want to say to Hajar you're malicious, and she showed an evil opposite to the beauty offered to her by God, because she preferred Dounia to Jamal, because Dounia has a very weak voice and you can't even hear it with the music... Hajar you're afraid of Jamal like most students...An advice to the students and the viewers to vote for the best and not following origins so that the program can truly be called Maghreb Star Academy...Please because I feel that there's a great discrimination from Maghreb teachers, try to be realistic to look like Lebanese...this an advice to myself and to you...I like Hamid, Jamal, Badrou, Farid, Farah, Yousra, Firas and the Libyan, really without discrimination because we're all Arabs namely Maghrebians, think seriously about that, finally I wish happiness and luck to everyone, I love you all...Salam

hassan Posted 2007-05-23

My Algerian, Libyan, Tunisian, Moroccan brothers, you should be one people, forgetting geographical borders. We have to encourage all these students without partiality or discrimination because they're all stars and I love them all, and anyone who leaves the Dar makes me sad, with success, Hassan the Moroccan

minos_560@hotmail.com Posted 2007-05-23

Hi everyone. So, I love you, especially Hajar, Farah, Abdel, and Hamid. Long Live Morocco. Farhouna Wjahna

siham de maroc Posted 2007-05-23

Hi, to all the candidates. I like Badro and Hajar. Hi to Jamel. –Siham from Ouija

fatima zahra Posted 2007-05-23

I am Fatima al-Zahra from Salé. I love you very much Firas and I wish you a long successful career with Star Academy, along with Soraya, and warm greetings to all contestants from Algeria, Morocco, Libya and Tunisia.

mina Posted 2007-05-23

The proverb says, my brother and I are against my cousin, and My brother, my cousin and I are against the enemy. This is an initiative of the star, and we have to encourage them a lot even if it's not better than Lebanese star which succeeded thanks to Arab Maghreb students. I encourage Maghreb star and wish them success

lyes Posted 2007-05-24

Star Academy Maghreb is the best. I really do not get why people are getting so angry about this Star Academy. We finally have our own Star Academy!!! Plus, this is the first time!!!

hanane mghari Posted 2007-05-24

Hi, I love you so much, Hajar and Farah… and Hajar again, because you are the star of Morocco and of the Maghreb. I love you. HAJAAAAAAAAAAAR and FARAH!

حكيمه من الشاون Posted 2007-05-24

By the way guys if you have a nice thing say it otherwise keep your opinion for yourself, like the sister who is offending the director Khadija, why all this hatred my sister, you should have a big heart, it's a nice program appropriate for us or do you want it to be like Lebanon star which is all ads don't forget that participants in the Maghren star are four countries while particpants in Lebanon cover all the Middle East, everything is proportional, so please respect others, God bless you, with my greetings to readers

Assia Posted 2007-05-25

I wish for Nessma channel success, my thanks to all those who participated to Great Maghreb star academy, a greeting to all the students of the academy

سهام الليالي Posted 2007-05-25

My life to all participants, really there's nothing more beautiful than the voice of Hajar the Moroccan, I wish her success as well as to Ahmed, Hamid and Farid because their voices are great, but unfortunately Khairi has left the competition even if his voice was great, he just needed some hard work and would have become a real artist, with the best wishes

محمد عبدة Posted 2007-05-25

God with you

جارش جارش Posted 2007-05-25

To say the truth, I'm sorry for the departure of Khairi, I was so sad about that, and I wish he will come to see you soon, I wish success Ahmed and you're the star, Jarich from Libya, I love you Ahmed

kawetar Posted 2007-05-25

Hajar, Hamid, Farah and Kawtar from Maghreb star academy, Amal, Hana, Sofia, and Imane from Libyan star academy, Raja and Ikram from Iksir Anakar, Mona from Album program, Saad from Super star, Hikmat the singer all these are the Maghreb starac

مها Posted 2007-05-26

Please speak Arabic so that we understand you I'm from Saudi Arabia and love Badrou and Soraya! And also Farah and Firas but we don't understand the language

sabrina Posted 2007-05-27

I love you, Yosra. You are a STAR. I hate you, Hamid and Ahmed. I love you, Badro.

Sarah Posted 2007-05-27

You are the best, Farah. I love your look. Above all else, never change. –Sarah from Paris.

عهد Posted 2007-05-28

Ahmed I love you so much, All Libyans are with you and even your brother Khairi Dorouf

racha Posted 2007-05-29

I wanted to say if you can bring us Houari Doufane, Cheba Khira, Nasro and Redouane to entertain the prime better than singers you bring namely in this prime I didn't like them at the exception of Foudil. I want to say that the clothes you make the student wear belong, as we say, to the era of my grandfather, it's funny, and we're in 2007 we love fashion, thanks

وليد محمد على Posted 2007-05-29

By God this star is an absurdity and it's clear that its law is the law of the jungle, the survival for the strongest, and the strongest is Tunisia because the program is in its hands, why wasn't Dounia brought back after she was eliminated? When Yosra the Tunisian left, everything was upside down, and Yousra and Dounia were returned, because there's cheating and favouritism in the programme of mafias. Hamid goes out with honour like Khairi and leave them break it up as they like, but the administration should know that the viewers are human beings like you and have minds, bye

Anonymous Posted 2007-05-30

A step backward for the Maghreb union.

moh@med @minne Posted 2007-05-31

I love starac, I think that it's better than Lebanon starac, I hope that Moroccans will win

ليلي من ليبيا Posted 2007-06-01

I would like to say that Yosra is a star though I hate her, but it's clear that Khadija will give the title to Yosra or Soraya, today Ahmed sang well in the prime and they give him 14, he should have received a higher grade, but God is the Almighty, this is the will of Khadija, we'll vote to Ahmed till the end, an admirer from Libya

soukaina Posted 2007-06-02

Hi, how are you, I love you so much Hajar and Ahmed and hope to see you bride and groom inchallah, Hajar can you sing to me 'Lhorm Ya rasol Allah'.

مريم Posted 2007-06-02

Firstly, I congratulate Maghreb people for this great channel and its wonderful program, secondly the Maghreb people didn't imitate Lebanon, and supposing that they do that, it's as if it's Lebanon who innovated that program. Anyone who compares the two is crazy, and Maghreb star academy is successful, and if anyone says the contrary he shouldn't be from the Arab Maghreb countries. I want to ask you to translate French conversation because one of the Arab Maghreb countries doesn't speak French: Libya. I would also like to say that you're ignoring a second state of the Arab Maghreb states: the dear Mauritania, can you remember it even if none of the students is from there in your great program? You say the Great Arab Maghreb Morocco, Algeria, Libya and Tunisia, you should add Mauritania or the Arab Maghreb won't be complete if you ignore one of its states. I hope that you'll consider this point which is very very important. Thank you.

نرجس Posted 2007-06-05

I'm a fan of Star Academy Maghreb. This programme has informed me about the cultures of Algeria, Libya and Tunisia. Thanks to the students who all represent their countries in the best way. I encourage Hajar, Abdelhamid and Farid.

نرجس Posted 2007-06-05

Hajar and Hamid we love you so much, you've honoured us Moroccans, we're with you with our love, money and votes, so work hard in order to reach the final.